What began as a formidable undertaking to sift through nearly 10,000 proposed indicators to measure global progress on adaptation culminated in a landmark agreement on a streamlined set of 59 indicators at COP30. As discussions unfold at COP31, the focus will shift towards progress made in advancing the next phase of work under the Belém-Addis Vision on Adaptation adopted last year. The two-year program, expected to conclude at COP32, aims to refine indicator metadata and strengthen associated methodologies to streamline technical processes for indicator operationalisation. During this period, parties have been invited to test the finalised indicators and identify potential challenges to indicator adoption.
The list that has emerged after multiple rounds of negotiations and consultations with sectoral experts continues to be plagued by issues of lack of definitional and methodological clarity. For instance, 25 of the 59 indicators use terms such as “level of….” or “extent of” without mentioning how the outcome is to be measured. Examples include “Level of establishment of multi-hazard early warning systems”; “Extent of measures taken to improve and extend water, sanitation and hygiene services to populations disproportionately affected by climate change and to vulnerable groups relative to needs”, etc. This in turn raises the issue of potential non-uniformity in country responses, which are going to be based on their own interpretation regarding the measurement scale, unit and threshold and will make meaningful aggregation at the global level challenging. The indicators also vary in terms of their methodological maturity. According to the technical paper released by the Secretariat in September this year, established global methodologies are available for 8 indicators, partially developed methodologies exist for 29, and 21 lack global methodologies but can still be reported on using national data, while 1 has no methodology available.
Moving beyond the methodological challenges, the effectiveness of the indicators will ultimately be contingent upon the availability of data and robustness of national data systems. A preliminary mapping of the indicator list against data availability and reporting in India indicates that only a handful of indicators can be measured directly using available information. For the remaining, either the base metric exists, but adaptation linkage is missing or partial data exists that requires refinement, or fresh data needs to be collected. Some of the foreseeable challenges in the Indian context with respect to the indicators are discussed below.

Source: Author’s construction
First is the challenge of using existing data submitted as part of international frameworks such as the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) and the Sendai Framework to capture adaptation outcomes. Their applicability for this purpose may be absent or limited at best. For instance, the indicator “Level of water stress, including as an outcome of adaptation actions where applicable, accounting for relevant climate hazard intensity and/or frequency”, is related to SDG 6.4.2, against which India reports data on “percentage of ground water withdrawal against availability”. However, how much of the change is attributable to adaptation interventions or the impact of climatic variations is difficult to isolate. It is possible that during periods of drought, sustaining ground water levels would be considered as successful adaptation measures; however, it is unlikely to be captured by the variable in question. Conversely, it is possible that the variable records a reduction in groundwater stress which could be the outcome of improved rainfall conditions as opposed to concerted adaptation action. Thus, there is a need to add another layer to the base metric so that it can be used to meaningfully capture the required adaptation aspect.
Second is the challenge posed by indicators which may be complicated to measure and whose data requirements go well beyond what is routinely collected. For indicators such as “Level of food and agricultural yield in areas that are under management for food and agricultural production, including as an outcome of adaptation actions where applicable”, while data on agricultural yield exists, separating how it is affected due to climatic stresses or how it improved as a result of adaptation efforts would need econometric estimation of a counterfactual. Similarly, in the case of “Extent to which climate health services have remained at full capacity during and following climate-related events relative to pre-event service capacity”, event-specific information would need to be collected at a facility level in addition to having a pre-event baseline figure. Another case in point is that of measuring “Net savings as a percentage of gross domestic product from avoided losses”, which necessitates centralised record-keeping of disaster losses occurring with and without adaptive measures. Thus it is not just an issue of bridging data gaps, rather, of building domestic wherewithal in terms of infrastructure and institutional capacity to periodically collect and maintain said information.
The third issue pertains to the absence of systematic data collection and reporting mechanisms for cases where the initial groundwork has been laid, but the data are either not collected or not consolidated. For instance, while the National Disaster Management Authority (NDMA) has released a ‘Mental Health and Psychosocial Support Services in Disasters’ guideline, which recognises the role of climate change in influencing mental health outcomes, there is no dataset that measures the proportion of the climate-vulnerable population having access to mental health support services. Similarly, there are also cases where data may exist but only as isolated event-linked occurrences. Various state flood memorandums prepared to seek relief funds from the centre include details of the number of relief camps set up and the number of inmates housed. However, there is no consolidated national data source that can be used to report on the indicator “Number of people per 100,000 supported in planned relocation processes in response to water-related hazards, where adaptation measures were taken to ensure safety of populations”.
The fourth consideration involves the use of indicators developed by external entities, whose results and methodologies are unlikely to be endorsed by India. In fact, as per previous submissions on the matter, India has advocated for the use of official party-submitted data, as third-party submissions run the risk of undermining transparency in reporting. A case in point is the indicator “Level of resilience of ecosystems, including as an outcome of adaptation”, which is tied to the Bioclimatic Ecosystem Resilience Index (BERI). This index has been developed by Australia’s Commonwealth Scientific and Industrial Research Organisation (CSIRO) and forms a sub-component of the Environmental Performance Index (EPI), co-developed by Columbia and Yale University. India has expressed its reservations against the results of the EPI, arguing that the indicators appear to be based on “unfounded assumptions” and using “unscientific methods”. This highlights the potential ask by Parties for allowing independent validation of results generated using external datasets.

Thus, while the adoption of the 59 indicators marks an important milestone, their ability to meaningfully capture progress will ultimately depend on the availability of credible, consistent and adaptation-relevant data. Given that the GGA indicators are meant to be voluntary and non-prescriptive, India may consider adopting a phased approach starting by identifying the subset of indicators that best reflect its national adaptation priorities and for which reliable data already exist or can be fine-tuned with modest effort. Much of course will also depend on aspects being covered in the country’s forthcoming National Adaptation Plan (NAP), which is expected to be submitted soon and will potentially serve as the anchor for the indicator choice. Over time, operationalisation will require pre-identified baselines, stronger data collection and management systems, and institutional machinery for regular monitoring, validation and reporting across sectors and levels of government. Having nodal agencies specifically mandated to take charge of specific indicators may prove to be useful. A related aspect is having the technical and financial resources in place to sustain this set up, specifically at the sub-national level. Ultimately, the challenge for India will lie not merely in identifying what can be measured, but in building the institutional capacity to measure adaptation progress consistently over time.
(Views expressed are the author’s own and do not reflect those of ICRIER)
