Why industrial MSME clusters need a dedicated energy manager to turn the ambition negotiated at COP into action on the shop floor
At COP31 in Antalya, Parties to the Paris Agreement are considering the future of the Sharm el-Sheikh Mitigation Ambition and Implementation Work Programme (MWP), item 6 on the CMA 8 agenda. Both of its global dialogues this year, held in Yeosu in April and Sydney in September, were devoted to industry, and their reports point in the same direction. The technologies for cutting industrial emissions are largely known. What slows deployment, especially among small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) in developing economies, is thin institutional capacity, scattered technical assistance, weak data and a shortage of investment-ready projects. The Yeosu report goes a step further and names industry associations as platforms that can pool demand and lower transaction costs for smaller firms.
That leaves a practical question the dialogues do not fully answer: what does an MSME association need before it can play that part?

Spend time in an established Indian MSME cluster and a pattern repeat. A development agency commissions an energy study. A consultancy follows with a decarbonization assessment. A research body gathers data on processes and fuel use, an equipment supplier arrives to promote technology, and a government agency runs its own survey. Each brings useful expertise, and each brings its own questionnaire, timetable and data request.
The coordination falls to association office bearers and to owners whose first job is running a factory. Asked for the same figures again and again, firms tire of consultation, and what one project learns rarely reaches the next. The number of organizations involved is not the problem; clusters need their expertise. What is missing is a lasting technical counterpart who can join these efforts into one cluster-level agenda.
Practitioners working with small manufacturers elsewhere in Asia, Africa or Latin America will recognise this. The Yeosu report counts fragmented technical assistance and the cost of reaching dispersed SMEs among the barriers to financing industrial mitigation; the Sydney report adds shortfalls in technical expertise and workforce skills. Programmes run on short funding cycles, while changing how a cluster uses energy takes far longer.
Few small manufacturers can justify a full-time energy specialist. Decisions on electricity, fuel, process heat and equipment are taken by the owner or a maintenance supervisor. Audits identify savings, but the recommendations often sit unimplemented because nobody has the time or training to appraise the investment and see it through.

An Energy Manager hosted by the association would spread that expertise across the membership: supporting assessments, comparing technology options, helping firms build an investment case and tracking what gets implemented. This is the cluster-based, collaborative approach highlighted at both dialogues, made workable for firms too small to act alone.
The same person would be the association’s technical contact for government departments, development partners, researchers, consultants, technology providers, lenders etc. Before starting an assignment, an outside organization could learn from them what the cluster produces, which studies exist, what data is available and which interventions are under way by other organizations and if the same is aligned. Visits and data requests could be consolidated, and new work could begin where earlier work ended.
None of this should stop organizations dealing directly with enterprises. Firms must keep control of their own data, and any shared repository of audits, baselines and technology assessments needs their consent and clear confidentiality safeguards. Within those limits the association gains an institutional memory and, gradually, the ability to judge outside proposals and set its own priorities.
Finance is where the gap costs most. The Yeosu dialogue stressed upstream technical assistance, from energy audits and firm level road maps to viability assessments and financial structuring, as the way to create real demand for climate investment. The Sydney report lists weak capacity to prepare bankable proposals among the barriers. For small firms, that capacity has to sit close to the shop floor.
A MSME association Energy Manager could help members rank measures, prepare project reports, find applicable public schemes and approach lenders, and could coordinate measurement and verification (M&V) of the savings achieved. The role would complement accredited auditors, engineers and financiers, not replace them, starting with energy efficiency and moving, where viable, to electrification, renewable power, waste heat recovery and fuel switching.
India has a ready testing ground. ADEETIE, a Ministry of Power scheme implemented by the Bureau of Energy Efficiency (BEE), covers 60 industrial clusters across 14 energy-intensive sectors. Placing at least one qualified Energy Manager or Energy Auditor in each would be a concrete start. BEE and the Ministry of MSME, with state governments and SIDBI, could set common role descriptions, training and reporting protocols. The posts would need explicit funding; existing allocations should not be assumed to cover them. Larger clusters may need a full-time professional while smaller ones share one, and public or development-partner support could give way over time to membership fees and service charges.
Results should be judged by more than audits completed: fewer duplicate data requests, association staff trained, projects implemented, verified energy and emissions savings, and investment mobilized. The posts would also create skilled jobs for engineers, auditors and analysts, a contribution to the workforce side of a just transition.
International support has a part to play. Readiness and technical-assistance funding from multilateral climate funds and development banks usually pays for studies. Some of it could also support the people who make studies usable, as part of the institutional strengthening those funders discussed in Yeosu.
(Views expressed are the authors’ own and do not reflect those of ICRIER)
